top of page

New Year, New Me? Why Our Lives Don't Change Even After Reading All the Self-help Books

Writer's picture: Katrina Ray TandocKatrina Ray Tandoc

"As the allure of 'New Year, New Me' entices us with promises of transformation, remember that true change comes not from simply consuming self-help wisdom, but from the courage to look within and reshape our lives."


During my holiday break, I read many books and listened to many podcasts. While tuning in to a podcast discussing 2025 forecasts, the guest's thought-provoking question caught my attention: why is it that despite reading numerous self-help books promising life transformation, many of us find ourselves in the same position?

 

This prompted me to reflect on my personal journey. My introduction to self-help literature began when my father gifted me "How to Win Friends and Influence People" by Dale Carnegie when I was 14. He believed the book's teachings were crucial for success and personal growth.

 

Since then, I've delved into various self-help titles, such as "The Power of Now" by Eckhart Tolle, "The Road Less Traveled" by M. Scott Peck, and "The Secret" by Rhonda Byrne. While these books provided valuable insights, they didn't yield the life-altering results I had hoped for.

 

It's natural to turn to self-help books for guidance and inspiration, especially at midlife and beyond when we seek to redefine ourselves and our goals. But have you ever wondered why you still face the same challenges despite devouring countless self-help books? Let's explore this shared experience and uncover some reasons behind the self-help conundrum.

 

Information Overload

 

With abundant advice available, it's easy to become overwhelmed and struggle to discern which guidance to follow. When faced with conflicting strategies or an overabundance of information, we may find ourselves paralysed, unsure of which path to take, or feeling defeated before we begin.

 

The "Knowing-Doing Gap"

 

We may read book after book, absorbing information and feeling inspired in the moment, but fail to put that knowledge into action. This is known as the "knowing-doing gap." To bridge this gap, we must translate the information gathered into actionable steps and hold ourselves accountable for following through.

 

Expecting a Quick Fix

 

Self-help books often promise rapid transformations, yet lasting change takes time, dedication, and patience. Expecting immediate results can lead to disappointment and discourage us from continuing our self-improvement journey.

 

One-Size-Fits-All Approach

 

We are all unique individuals with different experiences, strengths, and challenges. A self-help book that resonates with one person may not be practical for another. Be discerning and seek out resources tailored to your specific needs and circumstances.

 

Resistance to Change

 

Let's face it: change is hard. Fear, inertia, or self-doubt can hinder our progress even when we know something could benefit us. Be gentle with yourself as you navigate the discomfort that often accompanies growth.

 

Lack of Support

 

Making significant life changes is challenging, and having a solid support system is crucial. Without encouragement and accountability from friends, family, or a coach, it can be easy to lose motivation or slide back into old habits.

 

So, how can we make the most of self-help resources and create lasting change?

 

Here are some suggestions:

 

  1. Focus on one book or strategy at a time, and give yourself ample time to absorb and implement its teachings.

  2. Break down the advice into actionable steps and create a plan for incorporating it into your daily life.

  3. Be patient and compassionate with yourself as you navigate the process of change.

  4. Seek out personalised advice or guidance tailored to your specific needs.

  5. Surround yourself with supportive individuals who encourage your growth and help hold you accountable.

 

Over the past 30 years, my life has changed in many small yet wonderful ways as I've focused on personal growth. Even though the self-help books I read didn't always give me the significant changes I'd hoped for, I'm still grateful for them. Each book taught me something new, made me more aware, and helped me grow. All these small changes added up, and I'm happy with the person I've become today.



Comments


bottom of page